Emma (Phillipa Soo) and Jesse (Luke Bracey) are the perfect couple. High school sweethearts who fell in love, got married and left their small town in Massachusetts, away from family expectations. Together, they live life to the fullest and seize every opportunity to travel the world until their marital bliss is ruthlessly cut short on their first anniversary, when Jesse disappears in a helicopter crash over the Pacific Ocean. Emma is destroyed and moves back to Massachusetts in an effort to mend her life back together. Four years later, Emma runs her family’s bookshop and has grown to like her new life. She runs into her old best friend, Sam (Simu Liu), who has always been secretly in love with her, and they become inseparable. Newly engaged, it feels like Emma’s second chance at happiness is finally here. Until an unexpected phone call changes her world forever again: Jesse is alive! Completely torn, Emma must now choose between a husband and a fiancé. She knows that she has to listen to her heart; she’s just not sure what it’s saying. Who is her one true love? What does it mean to love truly?